VINOLYNE
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Book
  • Recipes
  • About
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Book
  • Recipes
  • About
  • Contact

True Confession: Same Wine, Different Rating

10/18/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
Here's my confession, in writing: I unwittingly bought the same wine twice -- from the  national treasure in my neighborhood: The Wine House in Los Angeles. I don't know about you, but I'm looking for a new adventure with every trip to the wine store. It's easy to find something new because I study a different region every month or so. Right now, it's the Rhone. The wine I bought twice: Château Pégau 2016 Cuvée Lône Cótes-Du-Rhône.

​
The first time I bought the wine it was suggested by the knowledgeable staff at The Wine House. When I start a new region of study, I lean heavily on recommendations then grow bolder with each shopping trip. Today, I picked the wine myself, mostly because I recognized the winery, Château Pégau, from the podcasts I follow. Full disclosure: My choice was also influenced by the buyer-friendly price in a region that makes me want to cry when I pay my AmEx bill.

After rating the wine today, I was disappointed to realize I had already rated it, only one month prior! At first I cursed my horrible memory for the mistake. What a dummy! Then it dawned on me that this was an opportunity to assess the consistency of my tasting skills and consider the possible differences between bottles. Think about it: These wines were made by the same producer with the same grapes in the same year. The two bottles were cared for by the same shop. Could it be true that every bottle of wine is an individual, no different than ourselves?

Though my ratings and tasting notes were not wildly different, my emotional response to the wines were night and day. Let's compare the facts, as listed on the Vivino tastings:
September 2017
October 2017
Appearance: Clear, pale lemon wine with minimally cascading tears; unfined.
Appearance: Clear, pale, lemon-gold wine with some tears.
Nose: Clean, medium minus intensity nose of white wildflower, chalk and white peach nestled in underripe lemon, vanilla and room temp hot crossed buns.
Nose: Clean, medium intensity nose of white flowers, honey and green pineapple with tones of brie cheese rind, coconut and chalk (time on lees; large barrels or stainless/cement).
Palate: Dry, medium acidity, alcohol and body. Medium intensity flavors: white peach, young pineapple skin and wet stone with notes of chalk, white mushrooms and wet stone. Medium minus finish.
Palate: Dry wine, medium acidity and alcohol. Medium plus body. Medium intensity flavors: over-ripe sweet Myer lemons, white flowers and cucumbers with notes of old coconut, yogurt and zucchini skin. Medium finish.
Conclusions: Good; drink now. Delightful but not complex. Ideal with the brie/dried meat/spinach sandwich I am eating right now. 3.25
Conclusions: Very good; drink now. Clairette, Bourboulenc, Grenache Blanc, Ugniblanc. S. Rhone.
The score for the wines are .25 apart, if you read down to the final conclusions. Here's where the scenario gets tricky: the emotional response. The bottle in September: It's a nice quaff to go along with your sandwich. October: My God this is a good wine with a luscious mouthfeel and a backbone of acidity that tells me this vintner is on the mark. I'd like to give this wine a four! When I sat down today to give it an objective review, I dialed the score down to a 3.5, but doing so in no way diminished my euphoria.

How about you? Have you tasted two different bottles of the same wine and experienced both ho-hum and joyful moments? What do you think accounts for different emotional responses to a wine? Belly up to the bar and share your experiences. 
0 Comments
    Picture

    Author

    Lyne Noella

    Archives

    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    September 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017

    Categories

    All
    Alicante
    Alicante Bouschet
    Amaretto
    Amaretto Disaronno
    American Rhone
    Anchovy Pasta
    Anthill Farms Winery
    Anthocyanins
    Antioxidant
    Aragon
    Australia
    Barossa Valley
    Beaujolais
    Beaujolais Nouveau
    Beaumes De Venise
    Big Bear Lake
    Biscuits
    Blending Grapes
    Bolgheri
    Book
    Bordeaux
    Bottles
    Bottle Shapes
    Bouzy Rouge
    Bouzy Rouge De Margerie
    Bread
    Brett
    Brettanomyces
    Burgundy
    Bush-trained Vines
    Cairanne
    Calatayud
    California
    California Central Coast
    Campania
    Cannonau
    Cannonau Di Sardegna
    Carignan
    Champagne
    Châteauneuf-du-Pape
    Château Pégau 2016 Cuvée Lône Cótes-Du-Rhône.
    Château Rayas
    Cheese Pairings
    Chianti
    Chicken
    Chicken Flambé
    Chlorophenols
    Chocolate
    Cider
    Cinsault
    Corsica
    Côte D'Or
    Cotes-Du-Rhone
    Côtes Du Rhône
    Côtes Du Rhône Villages
    Cru Wines
    Derek Springer
    Dessert
    Dinner Recipe
    Doctor Lyne
    Drinkability
    Edina
    Eggnog
    Favorita
    Fermentation
    Fermented Vegetables
    Fiano Di Avellino
    Food And Wine Pairings
    Fortified Wines
    France
    Full-bodied Wines
    Galets
    Gamay
    Garnacha
    Garnacha Blanca
    Garnacha Peluda
    Garnacha Tinta
    Gigondas
    Girl With A Pearl Earring
    Gouais Blanc
    Grape Detective
    Greco Di Tufo
    Grenache
    Grenache Blanc
    Grenache Gris
    Grenache Noir
    Grüner Veltliner
    Henri Bouschet
    High Alcohol
    Homebrewing
    Honest Abe Cider
    Hot Sauce
    How To Drink Wine
    Israel
    Jancis Robinson
    Joe Schrader
    Johannes Vermeer
    Labels
    Languedoc-Roussillon
    Liguria
    Lirac
    Lodi
    Los Angeles
    Lyne Noella
    Maccabéo
    Mas Doix Les Crestes
    McLaren Vale
    Mistral
    MN
    Montagne De Reims
    Morgon
    Mourvedre
    Mourvèdre
    Navarra
    Northern Rhone
    Off-flavors
    Old Grapevines
    Old Vines
    Ordering Wine
    Order Wine At A Restaurant
    Pairing Wine With Food
    Paperwhite
    Parmesan
    Paso Robles
    Pasta
    Patrick Comiskey
    Peter Liem
    Philip The Bold
    Piedmont
    Pinot Noir
    Polyphenols
    Portugal
    Priorat
    Prohibition
    Provence
    Provence Rosé
    Rasteau
    Recipe
    Reims
    Rhone
    Rioja
    Rolle
    Rosé
    Rubrica
    San Luis Obispo
    Santa Monica Seafood
    Sardinia
    Secret Santa
    Semi-carbonic Maceration
    Sierra Foothills
    Society Of Barley Engineers
    South Africa
    Southern Rhone
    Spain
    Spanish Wine
    Syrah
    Tannins
    Tavel
    Temecula
    Thai Peppers
    The Wine House
    Torte
    Trader Joe's
    Vacqueyras
    Value Wines
    Vermentino
    Vermentino Di Gallura
    Vin Dous Naturel
    Vin Doux Naturel
    Vineyard
    Vinsobres
    Vista
    Vodka
    Volstead Act
    White Wine
    Wine
    Wine Appreciation
    Wine List
    Wine Pairing
    Wine Spectator
    Wine Tasting
    Wolf Oven
    Your Love Affair With Wine
    Your Palate

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.